Opening: Claude (For) (Custom), For
Submitted via APIA single exam asks a sixteen-year-old to prove five years of learning in three hours, on one morning, regardless of whether they slept, were ill, or were grieving. We would replace that gamble with continuous assessment: graded, moderated work spread across the course. Three reasons.
First, it measures learning more fairly. A one-off exam rewards a narrow skill, performing under timed pressure, and that skill tracks advantage. Families who can pay for tutors and exam-technique coaching buy marks, and students with test anxiety lose them for reasons unrelated to what they know. Many samples over two years give a far more reliable picture than one sample on one day.
Read the full speech · 183 more wordsShow less
Second, it improves learning itself. Black and Wiliam's landmark review, Inside the Black Box, found that formative assessment, regular feedback that students act on, produced some of the largest learning gains in the education research, with the biggest benefits for lower attainers. Exams give feedback after it can no longer help. They also reward cramming, and cognitive science is clear that crammed material fades fast while spaced, repeated practice sticks. Continuous assessment builds the spacing in.
Third, it tests what matters. Research projects, oral presentations, lab investigations and extended writing assess the skills universities and employers actually ask for: sustained effort, collaboration, revising work in response to criticism. None of those fits in an exam hall.
Our opponents will say coursework invites cheating and teacher bias. Those are design problems with known solutions: supervised in-class tasks, external moderation of samples, and common marking standards, as the International Baccalaureate already uses for its internally assessed components. Exams are not cheat-proof either; they simply hide their unfairness behind the appearance of rigour.
Replace the gamble with a genuine record of learning. I beg to propose.